top of page

In my suit, baking just for you at Sugar Daddy Baker 👔🍪

You know that "happy taste buds" feeling?! That’s what happens when you have a (big as your head) Chocolate Walnut Chunk cookie from Sugar Daddy Baker! Our home-baked goods are made in small batches, fresh to order, just for you, with the finest local ingredients.

Our Baked Goods

(B.A.Y.H.) Chocolate Walnut Chunk Cookies

$27 for 6

Our (Big As Your Head) Chocolate Walnut Chunk Cookie is what kick started our little biz, put us on the map, and is our “signature bake”!

Known for their perfect, crisp flavor, texture and whole walnuts, they’re huge and delicious!  Order by the cookie or in a 6-pack!


Vanilla Bean Shortbread

$27 for 6

Our delish Vanilla Bean Shortbreads are sometimes hearts, sometimes discs, sometimes flowers - but always buttery, vanilla yum! Choose from  Tye dye or color sugar dipped or vanilla bean speckle glazed, or go for a merry mix up! Order some today, or pre-order for your next event.

Ginger Cookies

$20 per dozen

A current seasonal fave, our “Gingies” are both soft and crisp at the same time, with just the right spice kick! Baked to order with a perfect sugar top, the Gingies are a real crowd pleaser! We love them with tea, and their delish flavor is a family recipe that is so unbelievable, you'll just have to try them for yourself.

Sold by the dozen


Our Story

Yes, I really do bake while wearing my suit!

I love to bake!  This all started because I would come home from work, not get out of my suit, throw on my apron, and bake!  Literally still in my suit!  👔🍪 I love the whole baking process.  We started out baking for family and friends and were encouraged to spread the cookie love. The (B.A.Y.H.) Chocolate Walnut Chunk cookie was the launching pad!  We believe in the value of homemade, small batches of quality cookies, just for you.  We treasure locally grown, fresh ingredients baked into family recipes that taste amazing!  We like to keep it simple and emphasize big flavors over flash. Thank you for your support - we love baking delish cookies and couldn’t do it without you eating them! Xxx

Reach Out
Reach Out

Shipping Information

Yes, we deliver!

Orders are shipped Monday - Wednesday in the US, via 2-Day USPS, $23 flat fee for Guaranteed Freshness

Please contact us below regarding specialty or bigger orders. We will gladly help and quote!

*Local pick up in Sea Cliff, Long Island*

**We accept payment via Venmo and Zelle**

Get in Touch
Get in Touch

How do I keep my purchases fresh?

Your cookies should keep in their packaging for a couple of days - if they last that long!  You can also store them in an air-tight container for longer freshness, or freeze them for up to three months.

Still have a question for us? Get in touch below!

Contact Us

Please fill out this form with any specific needs or questions you may have, and we'll get back to you as soon as possible!

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page